Is Your CRM System a Hoax?

That's the question Jerome Pineau asked clients of CRM software purchasers in a recent post on his personal blog.

Pineau was reacting to an article by Matt Wallach for Destination CRM Magazine, exploring the blurred distinctions between hosted CRM and on-premise CRM systems. Wallach called out unscrupulous vendors for passing off hardware installations as "SaaS" products, leveraging the hot market for cloud computing in the C-Suite.

Putting aside the ethical debate about how some vendors sell CRM software, Pineau challenges customer service professionals to ask what they want to get from CRM systems in the first place. Business intelligence tools have evolved to the point where they can generate reasonably good insight from the types of data once stored exclusively in CRM systems. What else, Pineau argues, can a company leader learn from CRM software that he or she cannot learn from taking their top five clients out to lunch?

For large companies with a handful of key clients, this might be the case. However, the CRM software market thrives by meeting the needs of small to medium business owners who rely on increasingly distributed sales and service teams to provide consistent client experiences. Companies may not have as simple a choice as abandoning CRM software for BI tools, but they do have the power to implement CRM systems more effectively. As Pineau points out, many failed CRM implementations stem from false hopes about what new software can do for a company's culture. When tools support a team's shared vision, that team can succeed.

Ultimately, the search for the best CRM software comes down to a solution that fits a team, a business, and a collection of customers. No CRM software can completely automate the customer relationship. And, as Pineau argues, a totally automated solution often loses credibility with customers who crave the insight and the empathy that only human agents can provide.